4 amazing pizzerias in Youngstown

When it comes to delicious pizza, Youngstown has a burgeoning culinary scene that delights locals and visitors alike. From classic pies to unique toppings, these four amazing pizzerias stand out for their innovative flavors, welcoming atmospheres, and commitment to quality. Whether you’re a traditionalist or an adventurous eater, each of these spots offers something special that will make you want to grab a slice and savor the experience!

Inner Circle Pizza

• Specialty: Signature thin-crust pizza with fresh ingredients and inventive toppings
• Ambiance: A casual yet vibrant gathering spot known for its lively atmosphere and friendly service
• Highlights: Inner Circle Pizza is beloved by locals for its flavorful thin-crust pizzas that are always made to order. The extensive menu features classics like pepperoni and sausage, but don’t miss the chance to try their standout specialty pizzas, like the BBQ Chicken or the Mediterranean with feta and olives. The open kitchen concept allows diners to see the pizzas being crafted, enhancing the communal dining experience. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, Inner Circle is a must-visit for supreme pizza lovers!
• Ideal for: Families and friends looking for a fun and casual dining experience with delicious pizza options

Wedgewood Pizza

• Specialty: Detroit-style pizza with a thick, crispy crust and unique toppings
• Ambiance: A cozy and inviting space with a laid-back feel, perfect for enjoying a casual meal
• Highlights: Wedgewood Pizza has carved out a niche in the local scene by showcasing the unique flavors of Detroit-style pizza. Their crispy, rectangular pies are generously topped and baked in well-oiled pans, delivering a deliciously crunchy edge and a gooey interior. Be sure to try their signature Wedgewood Supreme, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, and a medley of fresh veggies. The warmth and charm of the space make it an ideal spot for a relaxed dinner with friends or family.
• Ideal for: Pizza aficionados eager to taste a distinctive style of pizza that’s hard to find elsewhere

Pizza Joe’s

• Specialty: Traditional New York-style pizza with a variety of toppings
• Ambiance: A no-frills, casual pizzeria that's all about the pizza and the people
• Highlights: Pizza Joe’s prides itself on serving up classic New York-style pizza that satisfies cravings with every slice. Their thin, foldable crust is perfect for loading with your favorite toppings, and the fresh ingredients shine through in every bite. The pizzeria is a hub for locals, making it a great spot to grab a quick bite or enjoy a laid-back meal with friends. Don't forget to try their famous garlic knots as a perfect side to accompany your pizza!
• Ideal for: Casual diners looking for a classic pizza experience in a friendly neighborhood setting

Mezzo Restaurant

• Specialty: Gourmet wood-fired pizzas with seasonal ingredients
• Ambiance: An upscale yet relaxed dining environment perfect for a night out
• Highlights: Mezzo Restaurant elevates pizza dining with its gourmet wood-fired oven and meticulous approach to flavor. Their creative pies feature seasonal ingredients and unique flavor combinations, such as the Fig & Prosciutto or the Spicy Shrimp with jalapeños and roasted garlic. The beautiful interior and attentive service create an inviting atmosphere for both romantic dinners and celebrations. Mezzo is not just a pizzeria; it’s an experience that showcases the artistry of pizza-making at its finest.
• Ideal for: Foodies and couples looking to indulge in a gourmet dining experience

Extra Tips

• Check out each pizzeria’s social media pages for special deals and limited-time menu items.
• Consider visiting during off-peak hours for a more relaxed experience and quicker service.
• Don’t hesitate to ask for recommendations from staff—they often know the best items on the menu!

No matter your pizza preference, Youngstown's pizzerias promise delicious flavors and memorable dining experiences that will have you coming back for more. Grab your friends and family and treat yourself to one of these amazing spots—you won’t regret a single bite!