4 amazing pizzerias in New York City
By Editorial Team•

New York City, the culinary capital of the world, is renowned for its diverse food scene, and when it comes to pizza, it has some of the most iconic pizzerias that gastronomes simply can't miss. Whether you crave a classic New York slice or a unique artisanal pie, these four amazing pizzerias offer an unforgettable experience that will tantalize your taste buds and keep you coming back for more:
Di Fara Pizza
- Specialty: Legendary classic New York-style pizza topped with high-quality ingredients
- Ambiance: A small, no-frills pizzeria filled with the rich aroma of freshly baked pies and an authentic Italian vibe
- Highlights: Established in 1965 by the passionate Domenico DeMarco, Di Fara Pizza has earned a reputation as one of the best in NYC. Each pie is handcrafted with love, featuring a perfectly crispy crust, homemade sauce, and an abundance of fresh mozzarella and basil. The experience of watching the master at work is part of the charm, making it a pilgrimage for pizza lovers
- Ideal for: Those seeking an authentic New York pizza experience and a taste of history with every bite
Prince Street Pizza
- Specialty: Pepperoni slices that have achieved cult status among locals and tourists alike
- Ambiance: A bustling, vibrant counter-service spot located in the heart of Nolita
- Highlights: Famous for its thick, crispy, and slightly spicy pepperoni slices, Prince Street Pizza offers a unique twist on the classic pizza experience. Each slice comes loaded with flavorful toppings and a sauce that's both zesty and comforting. The atmosphere is always buzzing, making it a perfect place to grab a quick bite while exploring the dynamic streets of Manhattan
- Ideal for: Pizza enthusiasts looking for a quick and delicious meal in a lively setting
Roberta's
- Specialty: Innovative pies with fresh, locally sourced ingredients
- Ambiance: A trendy, laid-back restaurant with an outdoor garden setting in Bushwick
- Highlights: Roberta's has redefined the pizzeria experience by using seasonal ingredients to create unique flavor profiles. Their wood-fired pizzas, like the famous "Bee Sting," combine spicy honey and soppressata for a harmonious blend of sweet and savory. The vibrant atmosphere and community feel make it an ideal destination for casual dining and gathering with friends
- Ideal for: Those looking for a modern twist on classic pizza, with a focus on sustainability and flavor
Lucali
- Specialty: Hand-stretched pizza with a perfectly charred crust
- Ambiance: An intimate, candlelit setting that feels like a cozy Italian restaurant
- Highlights: Lucali is a beloved pizzeria that stands out for its artisanal approach to pizza-making. Each pie is crafted by hand, using high-quality ingredients and a secret family recipe for dough. The ambiance exudes romance and warmth, creating a perfect date night destination or a special occasion spot. The combination of the signature pies and a tailored experience makes it a gem in Brooklyn
- Ideal for: Couples or anyone celebrating a special occasion while indulging in exceptional pizza
Extra Tips
- Be prepared to wait, as these pizzerias can get crowded, especially during peak hours.
- Consider trying multiple slices at different pizzerias in one day for a true pizza tour of NYC!
- Bring cash; some of these spots might not accept cards, so it’s always good to be prepared.
Whether you're a lifelong New Yorker or a visitor exploring the city, indulging in these amazing pizzerias is a delicious journey you won't want to miss. Each offers a unique atmosphere and mouthwatering options that make leaving home worthwhile!
About the author
Editorial Team