4 amazing pizzerias in Milwaukee

Milwaukee, known for its rich cultural tapestry and vibrant culinary scene, is also home to some incredible pizzerias that promise to tantalize your taste buds. Whether you're a lover of classic pies or in search of innovative toppings, the following four pizzerias stand out for their unique styles, exceptional flavors, and inviting atmospheres. Get ready to embark on a pizza adventure that will make you want to leave home and indulge in these local gems!

Pizza Man

• Specialty: Famous for their creative and unconventional toppings, as well as a wide variety of gluten-free crust options.
• Ambiance: A lively and welcoming atmosphere, adorned with colorful murals and a vibrant bar scene.
• Highlights: Pizza Man has garnered a loyal following thanks to its innovative pies like the “Smoky Pesto Chicken” and “Buffalo Cauliflower” that push the envelope of traditional pizza. Their extensive beer and wine selection perfectly pairs with your meal, enhancing the overall experience. The pizzeria also features a cozy patio, making it a fantastic spot for sunny days.
• Ideal for: Those looking for a creative and companionable environment to enjoy artisanal pizzas, especially if you appreciate an inclusive menu.

Transfer Pizzeria Cafe

• Specialty: Neapolitan-style pies with an emphasis on fresh, high-quality ingredients.
• Ambiance: A rustic and casual setting with a blend of classic Italian charm and modern aesthetics.
• Highlights: Transfer Pizzeria Cafe is celebrated for its wood-fired pizzas that are crafted with love and precision. You’ll savor the incredibly thin and crispy crust topped with rich San Marzano tomatoes and handmade mozzarella. The inviting atmosphere encourages long meals with friends, and you'll have to try their delicious homemade garlic knots as an appetizer!
• Ideal for: Pizza purists and anyone who enjoys a straightforward, authentic pizza experience in a laid-back environment.

Balistreri's Italian/American Ristorante

• Specialty: Traditional Italian pizzas with a variety of toppings and classic Italian dishes.
• Ambiance: An old-world, family-friendly atmosphere perfect for gatherings.
• Highlights: Balistreri's is a longstanding favorite in Milwaukee, known for its handcrafted pizzas made using family recipes that have stood the test of time. The crust has a signature taste that comes from being baked in a gas pizza oven. Try the “House Special” pizza, loaded with fresh ingredients that highlight authentic Italian flavor. The warm, familial vibe makes it an ideal spot for a cozy night out with loved ones.
• Ideal for: Families and large gatherings looking for traditional flavors and a generous selection of dishes.

Good City Brewing

• Specialty: Unique pizza creations that pair perfectly with craft beers brewed on-site.
• Ambiance: A trendy brewery vibe that encourages camaraderie and good conversations.
• Highlights: At Good City Brewing, pizza is taken to the next level with inventive toppings and flavors that complement their craft beers. From a spicy “Chorizo & Pineapple” pizza to a vegetarian delight featuring seasonal vegetables, there’s something for everyone. The communal seating and vibrant atmosphere make it a great place to hang out with friends, enjoy live music, or catch a game on the screens.
• Ideal for: Beer lovers and social butterflies looking for a lively spot where great pizza meets craft brews.

Extra Tips

• Consider trying the daily specials or unique toppings that may not be on the regular menu!
• Many of these pizzerias can get busy, especially on weekends, so it’s a good idea to make a reservation if possible.
• Pair your pizza with a local beer or themed drink to enhance your meal experience.

With these four amazing pizzerias in Milwaukee, there’s no reason to settle for ordinary when you can enjoy extraordinary flavors and experiences. Whether you’re craving a classic slice or something out-of-the-box, let these local favorites satisfy your pizza cravings!