4 amazing pizzerias in Ithaca

Ithaca, New York, is not only known for its stunning gorges and beautiful lakes but also for its incredible culinary scene. Among its many delights, pizzerias stand out as beloved local spots that cater to a variety of tastes and styles. If you're a pizza lover or just looking for a delicious meal, these four amazing pizzerias in Ithaca are must-visit destinations that promise to satisfy your cravings.

amana

• Specialty: Wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizzas with fresh, locally sourced ingredients
• Ambiance: A warm and inviting atmosphere with a rustic touch, featuring an open kitchen for a view of the pizza-making process
• Highlights: Amana takes pride in its artisanal approach to pizza. Each pie is crafted with the finest ingredients, from handmade dough to seasonal toppings. The restaurant’s wood-fired oven creates a perfect balance of crispy crust and bubbly cheese, delivering a unique flavor profile that keeps patrons coming back for more. Pair your pizza with a glass from their curated selection of local wines and beers for an elevated dining experience.
• Ideal for: Diners seeking high-quality, authentic Neapolitan pizza in a cozy environment that feels like home.

Purity Ice Cream & Pizza

• Specialty: A delightful fusion of gourmet pizzas and homemade ice cream
• Ambiance: A casual and family-friendly eatery buzzing with activity, perfect for a relaxed meal
• Highlights: Purity Ice Cream has been an Ithaca staple for decades, known for its scrumptious ice creams and creative pizzas. The menu features a diverse array of delicious toppings, from classic pepperoni to inventive vegetarian options. What truly sets Purity apart is the ability to complement your savory meal with one of their artisanal ice cream treats. It's a unique spot where pizza dreams and sweet cravings come together, making it a great outing for families and friends alike.
• Ideal for: Those looking for a fun dining experience that pairs delicious pizza with out-of-this-world ice cream.

Collegetown Pizza

• Specialty: Slices and whole pies with a vast array of toppings, including vegan and gluten-free options
• Ambiance: A lively and casual setting that captures the energy of Ithaca’s college scene
• Highlights: Collegetown Pizza is a favorite among students and locals alike. With an extensive menu that offers everything from classic cheese slices to innovative specialty pies, there's something to please every palate. The friendly staff and bustling atmosphere make it a perfect stop for a quick bite or a late-night snack. Plus, their commitment to accommodating dietary preferences ensures that everyone can enjoy a slice of their delicious pizza.
• Ideal for: Pizza lovers in search of convenience and variety, especially those craving a late-night slice.

Handcrafted Pizza

• Specialty: Creative and craft pizzas with unique flavor combinations
• Ambiance: A hip and trendy space featuring modern decor and an open kitchen
• Highlights: Handcrafted Pizza sets itself apart by emphasizing quality ingredients and imaginative flavor pairings. Each pizza promises a harmonious blend of textures and tastes, appealing to adventurous foodies. Their menu rotates seasonally, ensuring fresh options and inspiring combinations that celebrate local produce. Coupled with craft beers and specialty cocktails, the entire experience is elevated, making it a delightful place to gather with friends for a memorable evening.
• Ideal for: Those with an adventurous palate looking to explore innovative pizza creations in a stylish setting.

Extra Tips

• Check each pizzeria’s social media for daily specials and limited-time offerings to enhance your experience.
• Consider ordering ahead during peak hours to avoid long waits and ensure you get your favorite pie.
• Don’t forget to leave room for dessert, especially at places like Purity Ice Cream!

No matter your pizza preference, Ithaca's vibrant pizzeria scene offers something extraordinary for everyone. So gather your friends, grab a slice, and savor the delightful flavors these local gems have to offer!