4 amazing pizzerias in Erie

Erie, Pennsylvania, may not be the first place that comes to mind when you think of gourmet pizzas, but this vibrant city is home to some incredible pizzerias that are redefining the way we enjoy this beloved dish. Whether you prefer a classic slice or a unique, modern twist, these four amazing pizzerias in Erie are sure to satisfy your cravings and leave you coming back for more.

Pie on the Fly

• Specialty: Artisan thin-crust pizzas cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven
• Ambiance: A cozy, modern space with an open kitchen where guests can watch their pizzas come to life
• Highlights: Pie on the Fly takes pride in using locally sourced ingredients to create seasonal menus that rotate throughout the year. Each pizza is crafted with care, featuring unique flavor combinations such as the “Buffalo Blues,” topped with spicy buffalo chicken, tangy blue cheese, and fresh scallions. It’s not just pizza; it’s an experience that celebrates the art of pizza-making.
• Ideal for: Foodies looking for a creative pizza adventure and a relaxed dining experience.

Voodoo Brewery

• Specialty: A diverse selection of pizzas featuring house-made dough and locally sourced toppings
• Ambiance: A lively brewpub atmosphere that embodies the spirit of Erie with an eclectic decor
• Highlights: Voodoo Brewery offers more than just great beer; their pizzas are a hit among locals and visitors alike. Try the “Voodoo Pie,” with spicy sausage, mushrooms, and a garlic-infused olive oil. The brewery atmosphere makes it a fantastic spot for friends to gather and enjoy both pizza and exceptional craft beer brewed on-site. Don't forget to pair your slice with one of their signature brews for a truly local experience.
• Ideal for: Friends looking for a fun night out filled with delicious food and craft beers.

Big D's Pizza

• Specialty: Traditional New York-style pizzas known for their generous toppings
• Ambiance: A classic pizzeria vibe with friendly staff and a laid-back atmosphere
• Highlights: Big D's is a local staple offering the perfect blend of tradition and flavor. Their pizzas are baked to golden perfection, featuring a crispy crust and ample toppings that make every bite a delight. With options ranging from classic pepperoni to creative combinations like the “Supreme,” loaded with all the fixings, Big D’s is all about delivering hearty, satisfying slices that feel like home.
• Ideal for: Families and anyone longing for that authentic pizza experience reminiscent of New York.

Casa di Pizza

• Specialty: Gourmet specialty pizzas with a focus on fresh ingredients and innovative toppings
• Ambiance: An upscale yet welcoming restaurant ideal for any occasion, from casual dinners to special celebrations
• Highlights: Casa di Pizza elevates pizza to a culinary art form, offering unique creations that celebrate global flavors. Consider the “Mediterranean Delight,” featuring roasted eggplant, feta cheese, and fresh basil, all drizzled with balsamic glaze. The vibrant atmosphere, combined with attentive service, ensures that every meal is memorable. The extensive wine selection pairs beautifully with every dish on the menu.
• Ideal for: Couples and anyone seeking a refined dining experience with extraordinary pizza.

Extra Tips

• Be sure to check the pizzerias’ social media pages for daily specials and events.
• Consider making a reservation, especially during busy weekends or special occasions.
• Don't forget to complement your pizza with a drink from their extensive beverage selections.

With flavors that will tantalize your taste buds and atmospheres that make for the perfect dining experience, these four amazing pizzerias in Erie are worth the trip. Step out, indulge in a slice (or two), and discover the culinary magic that this charming city has to offer!