4 amazing pizzerias in Amarillo

When it comes to pizza, Amarillo might not be the first city that comes to mind, but this Texas gem has some incredible pizzerias that will leave you craving for more. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice, gourmet toppings, or an inventive twist on a traditional favorite, these four pizzerias showcase the best of Amarillo’s vibrant pizza scene. Here’s a culinary journey that promises to tantalize your taste buds!

Big Pie In The Sky

• Specialty: Massive, New York-style slices that are piled high with toppings
• Ambiance: A casual and laid-back eatery perfect for gatherings with family or friends
• Highlights: Big Pie In The Sky is famous for its gigantic slices – each one larger than your average plate! Using fresh ingredients and traditional recipes, each pizza is hand-tossed and comes with a variety of classic toppings. The space invites you to grab a slice, enjoy a refreshing drink, and kick back in a friendly environment. It’s not just a meal; it’s an experience to enjoy as you watch your favorite sports teams on TV.
• Ideal for: Those looking for hearty portions and a fun atmosphere to enjoy great pizza with friends

Domino’s Amarillo

• Specialty: Customizable pizzas with a focus on speed and convenience
• Ambiance: Delivery-friendly and take-out focused, perfect for a night in
• Highlights: While Domino’s may be a chain, the Amarillo location puts a local twist on delivering pizza quickly and efficiently. With the option to create your own pizza, you can choose from a wide array of toppings, sauces, and crusts. The iconic tracker system keeps you updated while you relax at home, making it a go-to spot for those cozy nights in front of the TV—with pizza right at your fingertip!
• Ideal for: Busy individuals or families looking for a quick and satisfying meal without the need to dine out

Fire Pie

• Specialty: Wood-fired pizzas with a gourmet flair
• Ambiance: An artsy and vibrant environment that feels like a community hub
• Highlights: Fire Pie takes pizza-making to the next level with their artisanal approach. Each pizza is cooked in a wood-fired oven, giving it a perfectly crisp crust paired with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The chefs are innovative, crafting unique combinations that push the boundaries of traditional pizza. From seasonal specialties to gluten-free options, every visit promises something new for your palate. Plus, the lively atmosphere encourages a sense of community, making it a fantastic place to wind down after a long day.
• Ideal for: Foodies looking to indulge in gourmet flavors while enjoying a fun and social atmosphere

Pizza Planet

• Specialty: A creative selection of specialty pies and calzones
• Ambiance: A fun, family-friendly spot that appeals to all ages
• Highlights: Vibrant and whimsical, Pizza Planet is designed to cater to pizza lovers of all ages. The menu features a mind-boggling array of specialty pizzas, including their famous BBQ Chicken Pizza and the Spicy Pepperoni Delight. Their calzones are equally impressive, stuffed with savory ingredients that will leave you wanting more. With a welcoming and playful environment, it's the perfect place to bring the whole family for a fun outing filled with laughter and great food.
• Ideal for: Families and groups looking for a fun dining experience with delicious options for everyone

Extra Tips

• Check each pizzeria’s website or social media for special deals and events.
• Consider calling ahead for larger groups or peak hours to ensure you get a table.
• Always have room for dessert—many pizzerias offer delectable side treats that are worth the indulgence!

No matter what kind of pizza experience you’re after, Amarillo’s top pizzerias serve up more than just slices; they offer a celebration of flavors, creativity, and community that you won’t want to miss!